The Bi-Weekly Mortgage - Who Needs It?
Have you received an advertisement
offering to save you thousands of dollars on your thirty-year mortgage and cut
years off your payments? With email "spam" becoming more pervasive as everyone
tries to "get rich quick" on the internet, these ads are popping up with
troublesome regularity.
The ads promote the "Bi-Weekly Mortgage" and for the most part, do not come from
a mortgage lender. Exclamation points punctuate practically every claim:
- No closing costs!
- No refinancing!
- No points!
- No credit check!
- No appraisal!
- Save thousands!
- Cut years off your mortgage!
To achieve these wonderful savings all you have to do is allow half of your
mortgage payment to be deducted from your checking account every two weeks.
It's easy. Of course, there is a small "set-up fee" and usually a
"transaction fee" with every automatic deduction.
Essentially, the ads are truthful in almost every respect.
They just want to charge you money for something you can do on your own for
free.
The Basics:
Normally, you make twelve mortgage payments a year. Since there are
fifty-two weeks in a year, a bi-weekly mortgage equals 26 half-payments a
year. The equivalent would be making thirteen mortgage payments a year
instead of twelve. By applying that extra payment directly to the loan
balance as a principal reduction, your loan amortizes more quickly,
requiring fewer payments.
You save money. The ads are true.
How it Actually Works:
You cannot simply mail in half a payment every two weeks to your mortgage
lender. Since they do not accept partial payments for legal and accounting
reasons, the mortgage company would just mail your half-payment back to you.
Instead, the bi-weekly mortgage company is an intermediary between you and
your mortgage lender. They automatically debit your checking account every
two weeks for half of your mortgage payment, then place your funds into a
trust account. Basically, this is just a holding account for your money. In
another two weeks, there is another automatic deduction from your checking
account, and so on. When your mortgage payment is due, your funds are
withdrawn from the trust account and forwarded to your mortgage lender.
Since you are placing funds into the trust account faster than your mortgage
payments are due, you eventually accumulate enough money to make an "extra"
payment. The way the cycle works, this occurs once a year. The extra payment
is applied directly to your principal balance, which causes your loan to
amortize faster, pay off more quickly and save you thousands of dollars.
Potential Problems with the Trust Account
Because your funds are held in the trust account until your mortgage payment
is due, there are potential dangers. Not only are your funds held in this
account, but so are the funds of everyone else enrolled in the bi-weekly
program. That is a lot of money.
Most likely, there will be no problems.
However, if there are accounting errors, mismanagement, or even fraud, your
mortgage payment might not get made. The first hint of a problem will
probably be a phone call or letter from your mortgage lender, but not until
after your payment is already late. Since responsibility for making the
payment rests with you and not the bi-weekly payment company, you may find
yourself digging into your personal savings to make the payment directly --
even though the bi-weekly payment company has already collected your funds.
Later you can work out the trust account problem with your bi-weekly payment
company.
The Cost of the Bi-Weekly Mortgage
There is usually a set-up fee that runs between $195 and $350, depending on
how much sales commission is paid to the individual or company setting up
the account for you. You also pay a transaction fee each time there is an
automatic deduction from your checking account and sometimes also when the
payment is made to your mortgage lender. There may also be a periodic
"maintenance fee."
Meanwhile, whoever controls the trust account is earning interest on your
money.
Savings of the Bi-Weekly Mortgage
By making principal reductions using the bi-weekly mortgage program, your
mortgage will amortize more quickly, saving you money. How quickly your loan
pays off depends on your interest rate and when you begin making the
bi-weekly payments.
On a $100,000 loan at today's interest rate of eight percent, your first
principal reduction would probably be a year from now. Assuming the
principal reduction is equal to one monthly payment ($733.76), you would
save $43,852 over the life of the loan and pay it off almost seven years
early.
However, you have to deduct from those savings any amounts you paid in
set-up, transaction, and maintenance fees.
No-Cost Alternatives to the Bi-Weekly Mortgage
Instead of hiring a company to manage your bi-weekly payment, you could
accomplish essentially the same thing on your own for free. Just take your
monthly payment, divide it by twelve, and add that amount to your monthly
mortgage payment. Be sure to earmark it as a principal reduction.
The first way you save is that you do not have to pay any fees to anyone.
It's free.
In addition to not paying fees -- using the same example as above -- your
total savings on the mortgage would be $45,904. Plus the loan would be paid
off three months quicker than with the bi-weekly mortgage. The reason you
save more is because you are making a principal reduction each month,
instead of waiting for funds to accumulate so that you can make one
principal reduction a year.
Self-Discipline?
The bi-weekly mortgage companies claim that homeowners are not disciplined
enough to follow through with principal reduction plans on their own. They
suggest the reason for setting up the bi-weekly mortgage enforces discipline
upon you, and by doing so, they save you money.
However, in this internet age, banking on line and automatic deductions are
readily available. You can set up your own automatic deductions including
the additional principal reduction and have it go directly to your mortgage
lender. Since the deduction occurs automatically, just like with the
bi-weekly mortgages, self-discipline is not a problem. Once again, you don't
have to pay anyone to do it for you and you save even more money.
Conclusion
The bi-weekly mortgage plans do not really do anything except move your
money around and charge you for it. Plus, even though the danger is
negligible, you must trust someone else to hold your money for you. If you
can do the very same thing for free, plus save yourself even more money by
doing it on your own, why pay someone else?
The bi-weekly mortgage plan - who needs it?
If your goal is principal reduction and saving money, then it is a good
plan. If you do it on your own instead of paying someone else to do it for
you, then it is a great plan.